|
f18:
Summary
1.1 The subject of
water fluoridation has been debated for many years.
However, early biased research has unfairly
influenced public opinion.
1.2 Water fluoridation
is a victory of propaganda over the truth.
1.3 Water fluoridation
can divide communities.
2.1 Fluorine is a pale
yellow gas which cannot exist in nature on it's own.
It has to react with other elements to form
fluoride. This is achieved by 'stealing' an electron
from another element. When obtaining an extra
electron, fluorine becomes known as fluoride ion.
2.2 Fluorine is also
known as the 'devil's element' for good reason. It
is poisonous, corrosive and the most chemically
‘active’ of all the non-metallic elements (and the
most electronegative and reactive of all elements).
2.3 Fluoride is a
trace element and appears in the environment in very
tiny amounts.
2.4 Phosphate rock is
now widely used to produce fertilizer. This is where
fluoride (which is added to water) normally comes
from. Sodium fluoride has also been provided by the
aluminium production industry.
2.5 The fluoride
normally used to fluoridate UK water supplies is
called hexafluorosilicic acid (or sometimes
hydrofluorosilicic acid). It is also referred to as
a 'silicofluoride'. These are artificial fluorides.
2.6 Currently, only
two types of silicofluoride are allowed to be added
to water. Hexafluorosilicic acid (H2SiF6)
is the first and Disodium Hexafluorosilicate is the
other (Na2SiF6).
2.7 Fluorosilicates
are contaminated with toxic chemicals such as lead,
arsenic and mercury.
3.1 Water can contain
amounts of natural fluoride usually around 0.1 to
0.2 parts per million (ppm) of volume.
3.2 Artificial
fluorides are extremely toxic and very soluble.
However, when artificial fluorosilicates are added
to water, it is assumed that all the fluorine
becomes relatively insoluble fluoride ions. However,
there is no published evidence to show that this
happens and it is thought that only about two thirds
of fluorine in artificial fluorosilicates produce
fluoride ions. Other atoms of fluorine may produce
more exotic and dangerous fluoride compounds.
3.3 Exposure to
fluorosilicates in their raw state can result in
either serious injury, or even death.
4.1 River water can
contain significant amounts of pesticides,
herbicides, fungicides, etc.
4.2 All supplies of
water are likely to contain some amounts of
aluminium from the water treatment process. Lead
from plumbing may also appear. The big question is
how does aluminium with fluoride react when water is
heated (as in making beverages and cooking)?
5.1 Water fluoridation
became a reality when certain industries had to find
alternative ways of disposing of their noxious waste
products.
5.2 Early history is
littered with examples of how 'vested interests'
ensured they infiltrated, controlled or manipulated
science and politics. As a consequence, toxic
fluoride wastes were sold to the people as a public
health measure - "garbage was turned into gold".
6.1 It has never been
proven (in the UK) that there is any essential
function for fluoride in the human body.
6.2 Different people
consume different amounts of fluoride depending on
their diet, regardless of whether or not the their
tap-water is fluoridated. Ergo, adding fluoride to
water is giving an indeterminate dose of fluoride to
everyone who is exposed to it.
6.3 Babies who are
exposed to fluoride via baby formula milk powders
mixed with tap-water are especially at risk.
7.1 Statistics used by
the pro-fluoride lobby to promote water fluoridation
are often limited, misleading or dishonest.
7.2 'League Tables'
are considered to be unscientific despite their
widespread use.
8.1 Some water
companies have previously expressed their concern at
adding artificial fluorides to water. This is based,
on part, upon the concerns of their customers as
well as a desire to protect their employees from
unnecessary and dangerous procedures.
8.2 Water UK is a
predominantly pro-fluoridation lobby which does not
represent the interests of consumers, merely a
selection of water companies who do not have the
courage to put their customers first.
9.1 Water fluoridation
costs more than is admitted. Shoddy statistics based
on poor quality evidence has been used to 'deflate'
the cost of this procedure.
9.2 Only about 2% of
all fluoridated water is physically consumed.
Therefore, 98% is completely wasted. The main target
of water fluoridation is children. For every £100
spent on fluoridation, it is estimated that less
than 28p worth reaches those under the age of 18.
9.3 Other hidden costs
include payment by the consumer to cosmetically
correct physical damage caused by fluoride to the
consumer's teeth.
10.1 There is an
element of crime and corruption involved in the
promotion of water fluoridation. This has been
demonstrated by victimisation of campaigners and
scientists in attempt to conceal the dangers of
fluorides.
11.1 The Water
Fluoridation Act 1985 was an example of how far a
government will go to force it's will upon an
unsuspecting population. The passage of the Bill was
affected by a two-line whip being issued to compel
some MPs to vote with the government.
11.2 Many MPs did not
vote or attend the debates on water fluoridation in
1985, thus they neglected their moral responsibility
to represent their constituents and protect them
from exposure to fluoridated water.
11.3 The Water Act
2003. Many MPs have again disregarded the truth
about water fluoridation by failing to properly
research the subject.
12.1 The British
Fluoridation Society (BFS) has received over £1
million of taxpayers money to promote water
fluoridation.
12.2 The BFS have not
provided an unbiased view on water fluoridation.
12.3 The BFS have been
severely criticised for misrepresenting the outcome
of the 'York Review' on water fluoridation
(1999-2000).
13.1 There are
wide-ranging vested interests in water fluoridation.
Too much money has been invested in the image of
fluoride to let it fail.
13.2 Those with an
interest in the promotion of fluoride, or water
fluoridation, include the phosphate fertilizer
industry, the aluminium production industry,
manufacturers of fluoridated toothpaste,
career-minded MPs, opinion polling organisations,
etc.
14.1 Endorsements of
water fluoridation are usually contrived and/or
based on limited evidence.
14.2 Some endorsements
come from organisations with no experience of water
fluoridation.
14.3 Endorsements are
sometimes made by different organisations but which
list have similar membership lists.
15.1 Water
fluoridation is open to numerous legal challenges
including those based on human rights.
15.2 In the early
1980s, a Scottish High Court ruling accepted that
water fluoridation is a form of medication.
16.1 Fluoride
accidents happen. Although they are openly reported
in the USA, evidence of accidents in the UK are
notoriously absent in the media.
16.2 One danger from
fluoridated water is to those with impaired kidneys.
A manufacturer of purification equipment for
hospitals stated that he had never been asked to
ensure that fluoride was removed from water. This is
despite recognition of the dangers by the former
DHSS.
16.3 Dialysis
treatments can use in the region of 120 litres of
water. This equates to a 'hit' of 120mg of fluoride
in one treatment with water that has not been
'purified'. Even then, the patient will still be
exposed to about 6mg of fluoride.
17.1 Dentistry has
it's own 'secret society', namely the USA-based
Delta Sigma Delta (DSD).
17.2 "Undergraduate Chapters are located in
dental schools and Graduate Chapters are located throughout the
United States of America, as well as Europe and Australasia.
The Supreme Council is designated as the administrative or governing body of
the fraternity."
17.2 "In Australia,
... during the past 20
years, all but two presidents of the Australian Dental Association have been
members of the society, and three fifths of the dentists on the Federal
Executive are members of this exclusive brotherhood. It's members also
figure prominently on most Federal and State Councils of the Dental
Association as well as State Dental Boards - the watchdogs of professional
ethics. In Britain, it seems that there are fewer than 2,000 Delta Sigs, but
some of the best known names in dentistry are members of this American
secret society."
|